Rental Property & Problem Tenants
How to Sell a Rental Property with Bad Tenants — Without Evicting Them First
Landlord fatigue is real. When tenants are not paying, are damaging the property, or simply will not leave, most landlords assume they have to fight through an eviction before they can sell. They do not. We buy with tenants in place.
In place
We buy with tenants still occupying the property
As-is
Rental wear-and-tear does not reduce our offer
$2K–$5K
Typical eviction cost — which you can skip
Why most landlords think they have to evict first
Traditional buyers — even investors — usually want a vacant property. They want to assess the condition, make repairs without coordinating around tenants, and market it cleanly. That means you either wait out the lease, negotiate a cash-for-keys agreement, or go through the eviction process.
An eviction (unlawful detainer) typically takes 30 to 90 days in a non-contested case and costs $2,000 to $5,000 in legal fees, though this varies by state and local court backlog. If the tenant contests it, you are looking at longer timelines and higher costs.
We are not a traditional buyer. We buy rental properties as part of our portfolio strategy, and we are experienced with managing occupied properties. The tenant situation transfers to us at closing — we handle the relationship from there.
What happens to the tenants when we buy
This depends on the lease terms and the tenant situation. If the tenant has a fixed-term lease, we are bound by that lease as the new owner — the same as any other buyer. If the lease is month-to-month, we can issue notice according to local law.
We are direct with you about this: we are not buying problem rentals to keep them as rentals. We typically rehabilitate the property and resell it. But how and when we deal with the tenant situation after closing is our problem, not yours. You close, you get paid, and you are done.
If you have a tenant you actually want to keep — a long-term, reliable tenant who just happens to be in a property you want to exit — let us know. That is a different conversation and we can work with it.
Property condition and rental wear-and-tear
Rental properties accumulate damage. Walls get scuffed, appliances wear out, carpets get stained, HVAC gets deferred. A retail buyer runs from all of this. We price for it.
We will inspect the property, estimate the cost to bring it to retail condition, and offer accordingly. You are not expected to repair anything before we buy. You are not expected to clean it out. You hand us the keys and we take it from there.
The only thing we need from you is honest disclosure of what you know about the property's condition — state law typically requires that regardless of who you sell to.
How we price a rental property
Rental properties with problem tenants or deferred maintenance get priced differently than owner-occupied homes. Here is our formula:
After Repair Value (ARV)
What the property will sell for after we renovate it and sell it retail.
Minus: Repair & Renovation Costs
Everything from cosmetic updates to major systems — we scope this during our walkthrough.
Minus: Tenant Resolution Costs
If the tenant situation requires legal action after we close, we factor that into our numbers.
Minus: Holding & Selling Costs
Property taxes, insurance, utilities, and resale costs we incur between purchase and sale.
Minus: Our Margin
We account for our business risk, transaction costs, and the work required to bring the property to market. Higher on complex deals.
= Your Cash Offer
The tenant headache becomes our headache. You get out clean.
We will not sugarcoat the offer. Problem-tenant properties with heavy deferred maintenance will land lower than a clean, vacant property. But that offer is real money in your pocket today, versus months of legal fees and zero rental income.
Common questions
My tenant has not paid rent in three months. Do I have to keep paying the mortgage while we close?
Once we are under contract, the closing typically happens within 7 to 14 days. You carry the mortgage for that window. We move as fast as the title work allows.
What if the tenants have damaged the property significantly?
Significant damage reduces our offer because it increases our repair costs. But it does not prevent the sale. We have bought properties in very rough condition. The inspection and offer process will account for whatever we find.
Can I use the security deposit in any way?
Security deposits belong to the tenants and must be handled according to state law — you cannot offset your losses with them unless the tenant caused documented damage that exceeds the deposit. We can discuss how deposits are handled in the closing process.
I have multiple rental properties I want to exit. Can you buy more than one?
Yes. We have done portfolio purchases. If you have multiple properties you want to sell at once, reach out and we will discuss a package offer.
Find cash buyers in your city
We buy houses in every state. Select your city for local market info and a direct offer.
Ready when you are
Get your cash offer in 24 hours
Tell us about your property. We will review it and get back to you with a no-pressure offer — no agent commissions, no obligation.